The Incompatible Food Triad

The Incompatible Food Triad (http://www.georgehart.com/triad.html)

Can you think of three foods, any two of which you like together, but that you dislike when all three are mixed together?  As a complementary question, are there three foods which you would eat together, but you wouldn’t eat any pair without the third?  George W. Hart discusses this question on his webpage entitled, “The Incompatible Food Triangle.”

The question remains unsolved.  Some have tried for an impossibility proof, i.e., they have tried to construct a logical proof that whenever all three pairings of food are okay, then the triad is also okay.  But Hart makes the good point that there are many reactions that require three reagents, but for which any two of the reagents do not react.  To the extent that cooking is chemistry, then, it would be difficult if not impossible to rule out the concept of an incompatibility triad a priori.

Some interesting triads have been proposed, to be sure: {chocolate, chicken, honey}, {salted cucumbers, sugar, yogurt}, and {tea, milk, lemon juice} to name a few.  But I would argue that none of these combinations offers a satisfactory solution to the incompatible food triangle problem.  Chocolate honey chicken sounds, to be perfectly frank, delicious, at least to anyone who already enjoys mole.  Salted cucumbers, sugar, and yogurt sounds like a sweeter version of Indian raita.  And the last triad hardly obeys the rules of the game: milk + lemon juice is not a good pairing of foods on its own, as the lemon juice would curdle the milk, leaving a disgusting slurry of gelatinous lactose blobs in acidic juice.  The best response to the puzzle that I can find was submitted by Noah Snyder and his colleagues at U.C. Berkeley.  They suggest the following three items: (1) a shot of tequila, (2) a shot of tequila, and (3) a shot of tequila.

Some refuse to respond to the question at all.  One person wrote back, disgusted with the question and what it implies about the human nature: “I am baffled, shattered, and destroyed by the mind-numbing pointlessness of The Incompatible Food Triad experiment.  It makes me ill.  I promise you, sir, I will never again be the same after witnessing the sheer mind-blowing uselessness of that puzzle.”

Despite the wide range of responses that the incompatible food triangle problem elicits, the challenge remains: Find a set of three foods such that any subset of two of the foods tastes good together, but for which the complete set is disgusting.  And of course, this problem begs to be generalized to the N-choose-k question: Can you find N foods such that any k of them taste good, but all N are distasteful?

Bacon, Bacon, and more Bacon

The question that everyone asks themselves every morning at breakfast is: does bacon go well with everything? Now, the question is very vague: can it combine with foods you don’t like? Can it combine with things that aren’t food? Does it only count as a combination if it’s baconlicious? Thankfully, we have the rules to sort out this question: if I combine bacon with another food I like, will I get something I still like? This controlled variation allows us to apply the scientific method to our work.

Of course, we want foods that don’t taste good together. But with bacon we were stumped. It seemed like every combination we could think of would still taste good. Seeing too many variables, we decided to narrow it down and test on only the bacon strip with breakfast foods. This is the most common time to eat bacon (though it should be eaten at every opportunity) and the most common foods we might combine it with. So we threw the kitchen fridge at our test and tried it all with bacon, suspecting that there was some ancient secret combination of two foods (one of which is bacon) that would taste awful together. The following documentary presents our most important discoveries in deliciousology, baconography, and baconometry. You can thank us later.

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gvVCIdc61Q%5D

The Great Tournament

Here at IfYouLikeA we have a commitment to bad food. We stand by our word that the food must be bad. But, as you have probably noticed, there are exceptions. These exceptions are failed attempts. And we do not take failure lightly. We want all our combinations to pass. We want everything we make to be disgusting. And so we made the greatest tournament of all time.

Bigger than March Madness. Bigger than the Olympics. Bigger than the Super Bowl. This tournament has revolutionized the entertainment industry as we know it.

 

How it Works

All our starting foods and their combinations.

All our starting foods with their partners. 32 total foods, 16 combinations, 1 great time.

Our food tournament works almost in reverse. We take two randomly generated foods (taken from a list of foods we like) and combine them in a randomly selected way. We then proceed to evaluate the taste of the foods in our normal manner. The goal is, of course, to make something vile. But we also realize that when foods are combined randomly in random ways, there is the potential for good food, or as we know it, failures. So our tournament combines foods together, and if they fail they must continue onwards to be combined randomly with another failure. If they pass, they are celebrated and are allowed to exit the tournament early.

The Bracket

The Bracket

Cole made a nice program that chose our foods and way of combining them, so we generated 16 random food pairings and combining methods for all possible scenarios. Here is a picture of our bracket so you can track the foods that we consumed.

As you can (hopefully) see, some combinations look like easy failures (a.k.a. they should taste good). There are some debatable ones. And there are some that look bad. Our hope is that everything passes in the end.

We hope the bracket makes sense. We start with all our foods, then combine combine them with the method shown until it provides us with something truly vile.

That delicious mix

The “winner” from the Eastern Conference.

 

Early Rounds

Cole and Bronwyn sampling some unknown foodstuff.

Cole and Bronwyn trying some unknown food.

The early rounds of this competition went smoothly. This was rather unfortunately. Glacier Freeze Gatorade and chamomile tea, for example, was extraordinarily good and something that we all thought was better than either food separately. Clearly a failure. And when I say “we all,” I mean Cole, Simon, and Cole’s friend Bronwyn, who helped us out cooking, cleaning, and consuming. I want to take the time now to thank her for putting up with our shenanigans and helping us make food. It’s always helpful to have someone else there.

Other foods were also clearly failures. Beefstick and decorative sprinkles was just crunchy beefstick, and salmon and “smiling lady” brand (we don’t actually know the real brand name) hot sauce were things that often go together.

But there were those foods (well, one food) that some might consider debatably good. The Doritos Locos Tacos from Taco Bell blended with Kettle brand salt and vinegar chips was just barely palatable. But it only took till the next round for us to find it inedible. Here’s a quick little video to show you how it all went down: What a color! What a color![/caption]

Another rather disgusting food type was our baked hummus blend with clam chowder and ground cocktail shrimp and mustard. Personally I think it was the baking that did this dish in. But it was so unspectacularly bad that it provided no good or entertaining footage. Doubly bad.

The flavor wasn’t that bad, actually. It was a combination of texture and aftertaste that made this dish inedible. It’s one of the few indescribable bad foods I’ve eaten.

 

The End Game

Just some stuff we made

Some stuff we made. Dare you to guess what’s in it.

The later rounds got progressively worse as more foods were added, which was the idea. But they were still not actively disgusting. And we might need to remind you that it takes an actively disgusting food for it to pass and leave the tournament. Even when the food looked absolutely horrid it was still palatable, and in some cases still tasted good. Powerful flavors that we liked, such as tapioca pudding and smiling lady brand hot sauce, pulled the foods through seemingly all on their own. And we managed, somehow to get a dish from both sides of the bracket into the finals. Somehow our random selector had failed us. But one last cooking instruction stood in the way of complete failure: serving the two dishes shaken, not stirred.

So for those of you who worked it out from the bracket, that means that the following foodstuffs were put into our mouths:

The Final Product

The Final Product.

Dish 1 contained sliced strawberries boiled with candied ginger, ground together with baked popcorn and orange juice, used as a dipping sauce for Wheat Thins fried with oatmeal that was microwaved with a grilled cheese with carrots.

Dish 2 contained baked tapioca pudding and Pirate’s Booty, fried with a grind of caramelized onion and celery, blended with all of billed raw salmon and smiling lady brand sauce, microwaved with a blend of Glacier Freeze Gatorade and chamomile tea, blended again with a mixture of papaya and Triscuits boiled with ground peanuts and Eggo Waffles, added to a lemon lime slushy with mango.

Dishes 1 and 2 were served shaken, not stirred.

So you’re probably wondering how it turned out. You’re probably dying to know how it went. Was our tournament a complete disaster of delicious food, or did we actually succeed in creating a food Satan himself wouldn’t eat? Well, we have prepared a nice, concise, 8-minute video for you to watch. You’ll find the answer within. [youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLmyTCWasDw%5D

Bacon isn’t the Top Priority

Blasphemy, we know. But we have something better. The bacon can wait. You’ll agree with us once you see what we’ve done. Unfortunately it is taking longer than a day so we can’t actually give you all the information you want. And then the videos won’t show up for another week or so. But here are a few pictures to get you interested.

Here we go!

Wonder what all that food is for…

Look Decent

Don’t you just wonder what it could be?

Looks like soup/

Two bowls of soup. So what?

Something Big this Way Comes

Many of you will realize that it’s been a very long time since this blog was updated. There are many good reasons for that. The most important one is school. With finals, baseball, and the fact that we’re in different cities during the school year it is very difficult to get things done. And now that it’s summer I’m back in Portland but Cole is off in Boston. But despite the lack of activity on this blog, the team here at ifyoulikea… continues to work hard on making you projectile vomit into your computer screens.

Unfortunately, you’ll have to wait a while because Cole and I will not be in the same town until mid-August. But we can assure you, our loyal or random reader, that some big, big stuff is on the way. We are going to change the way you view the world.

And we’ll leave you with a teaser. Keep in mind this has to last till mid-August, so don’t spend it all in one place. With that in mind, highlight the space below and get ready!

A BACON UNIVERSE by Ryan Courtwright

It’s dangerous for a boy to love just one thing,
but bacon is salty and crispy with zing,

there is no cut, prep, or dish from New York
that would go without garnish in my world of pork,

there’d be slides of raw bacon and hotdogs with wraps,
presidents and mayors would sport bacon chaps.

Pancetta’s the forecast! It rains marbled blocks
down into my chocolates, our salads, and socks,

hunger would be cured by the slab or the pound,
caul fat and pork loin—shoveled in mounds!

After the storm, the temp would rise high,
bacon would lattice the tops of our pies.

Block parties sharing a flich, that’s a slab,
it’s all you would smell in the back of a cab,

the world would be bacon, but there’s just one glitch,
it still wouldn’t cure my bad bacon itch.

–curtesy of BaconFest Chicago

Mahi Mahi Chip Cookies

From the IfYouLikeA kitchen, we bring you an original recipe: Mahi Mahi Chip Cookies!

Do you like chocolate chip cookies? Of course you do. But what have you thought about substituting in for the chocolate? Betcha didn’t think about that! Well we at ifyoulikea did. And we came up with something amazing: Mahi Mahi Chip Cookies!

Here are just a few of the rave reviews:
“It’s not offensive at all!”
“I’ve had things that tasted like this!”
“Not that strange!”
“It’s hard to figure out what’s wrong with it!”
“It’s not bad!”

If this hasn’t got you salivating, just check out the video. Bring a towel so the drool doesn’t damage your keyboard.

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcwK2vQlG6Y%5D

Macalester College Students Doing the Right Thing

We all love mixing foods, and the students at Macalester College up in Minnesota appear to have the art mastered. If only they would make foods they didn’t like…

A special shout out to our buddy Clemens (1:30 onwards). He knows what he’s doing with his food. Keep at it, Mac!

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=VExgRp7biOQ%5D

Fruity Popcorn

I will first apologize for the lighting. Our kitchen here has some interesting light bulbs.

Anyways, we all know that fruit cups are amazing. And popcorn is amazing. And cream of mushroom soup is amazing. If you like a…

 

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xr7Dwblq1mg%5D

Good Morning Mixes

Looking to spice up your morning coffee? Well, my friend across the hall decided to put a twist on his daily cup o’ Joe. I apologize for the nasty camera angle; I had to grab an iPhone before he got started (not everything we do is on camera) and didn’t really figure out what was going on until it was too late. Anyways, enjoy!

[youtube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_4fzKAf71jM%5D

Super Bowl Sunday

Yes, ladies and gentlemen. It is Super Bowl Sunday! The day when all the people in the house gather around the television and, for the first and only time all year, pay attention to every single commercial. Yes, the Super Bowl gives us great joy. But it is also a time for great food consumption. We figured we could give you a few ideas on how to eat your typical Super Bowl snacks this year. But if you’re actually a real fan of the event, you are already almost certainly in front of the couch or outside playing football. That’s fine and dandy, but you’ve never had Super Bowl food like this:

Looks so good you don't want to eat it.

Dip your favorite fan into your favorite player!

Make one of these and you will never be forgotten. Got any other ideas? Send them our way!